P5 Payment Change Calculator

Dec 2025 vs Jan 2026 — Cascading Bucket System

Your Herd:
%
%
5.90%
T1 Only(<2.0)
T1+T2 💰(2.0-2.2)
T1+T2+NP(>2.2)
Butterfat %Protein %
3.0%3.1%3.2%3.3%3.4%3.5%3.6%
4.0%
+3.32%
+3.33%
+3.34%
+3.35%
+3.36%
+3.36%
+3.37%
4.1%
+3.18%
+3.31%
+3.34%
+3.35%
+3.36%
+3.36%
+3.37%
4.2%
+2.94%
+3.06%
+3.18%
+3.30%
+3.36%
+3.36%
+3.37%
4.3%
+2.71%
+2.82%
+2.94%
+3.05%
+3.17%
+3.29%
+3.37%
4.4%
+2.49%
+2.60%
+2.71%
+2.82%
+2.93%
+3.05%
+3.17%
4.5%
+2.39%
+2.38%
+2.48%
+2.59%
+2.70%
+2.81%
+2.92%
4.6%
+2.40%
+2.39%
+2.38%
+2.37%
+2.47%
+2.58%
+2.69%
4.7%
+2.41%
+2.40%
+2.39%
+2.38%
+2.37%
+2.36%
+2.47%
4.8%
+2.42%
+2.41%
+2.40%
+2.39%
+2.38%
+2.37%
+2.36%

December 2025

Ratios: T1 < 2.0 · T2 2.0–2.2 · NP > 2.2

  • Fat: $/kg
  • T1 Protein (<2.0): $/kg
  • T2 Protein (2.0–2.2): $/kg
  • No Pay (>2.2)
  • OS: $/kg

January 2026

Ratios: T1 < 2.0 · T2 2.0–2.2 · NP > 2.2

  • Fat: $/kg
  • T1 Protein (<2.0): $/kg
  • T2 Protein (2.0–2.2): $/kg
  • No Pay (>2.2)
  • OS: $/kg

🎯 Target the Green Zone (2.02.2 ratio)

Producers in the green-bordered cells are maximizing income — they fill Tier 1 completely AND capture the Tier 2 protein bonus without spilling into unpaid territory.

Gold border = leaving money on the table. Grey cells with red border = producing unpaid milk — even if revenue goes up slightly, overall profitability goes down due to inefficiency.

Special thanks to Roger Boerson and Henry Verhoog for their insights on maximizing P5 payment strategies.